Drawer menu
Homeowners face all sorts of decisions when it comes to caring for their house: do you paint a room for a fresh look, revamp the bathroom, fix drafty windows, or take on a major home renovation? But one of the biggest questions on every homeowner's mind is: handyman or contractor? - Who do you call for each type of job?
Choosing the right person for the job is crucial - it determines the success of your projects, how much money you'll pay, and the long-term value of your home. Some tasks are easy-peasy, fast, and can be handled by a handyman in no time. Others require the expertise, training, and experience of a general contractor - especially when you're talking about structural changes, permits, or renovation planning.
This guide is here to break it down for you - when to call a handyman, when it's time to bring in a full contractor, and how to protect your home, your budget, and your future comfort by choosing the right path, with a few examples included. Along the way, we'll give you some real-life examples, talk through some repair projects and other projects, discuss the cost implications, safety concerns, and just how important it is to get the right company for the job.
A handyman is a jack-of-all-trades who handles everyday maintenance, minor repairs, basic installations, and small home projects that don't require special permits or structural work, using the right tools for the job. They're perfect for jobs like painting, simple fix work, minor electrical and plumbing tasks, basic carpentry, and installing fixtures, cabinets, or appliances.
On the other hand, a general contractor is a project manager who takes on larger renovation projects, supervises work crews, sources materials, obtains permits, understands the law and municipal codes, and ensures everything meets safety standards and building regulations as part of their business. They're in charge of coordinating teams, hiring tradespeople, and making sure the book does everything.
The real question shouldn't be who's better, but who's the right fit for the job you need done.
If your project is small, straightforward, and doesn't require any significant structural changes, a handyman is your guy (or gal)! They're efficient, affordable, and fantastic for home repair help on tasks that don't need technical licensing.
Here are some examples of the kinds of things that are perfect for a handyman:
Whether it's just touching up some scuffs or giving your wall a complete makeover, painting is one of the most common tasks for a handyman. They can repaint a room, refinish some doors, or refresh an accent wall. These projects take some time, but they don't need architectural planning or any major construction work.
Minor repairs like fixing a leaky faucet, tightening some fixtures, adjusting some doors, patching small holes in the wall, or removing a sticky window are all right up a handyman's alley. These little details make a big difference in how comfortable and pleasant your home feels, without needing a whole contractor team.
Tasks like gutter cleaning or light siding touch-ups are ideal for a handyman because they don't require significant structural changes. Keeping your gutters clean will prevent a range of long-term problems and save you money.
Handymen often install ceiling lights, bathroom fixtures, small appliances, shelving units, and other household items. They've got the right tools and skills to make sure everything is safe and working correctly.
Handymen can install new cabinets, fix some trim, assemble some furniture, and handle other small custom carpentry projects without getting into any major construction work, saving you dollars in the process.
Annual maintenance tasks, such as checking caulk, tightening hardware, or replacing worn-out parts, are suitable for handyman services.
In situations like this, calling a handyman is the quickest, most affordable, and most efficient way to get the job done.
If your project involves major structural work, a significant layout change, or the coordination of multiple subcontractors, you'll need a licensed contractor.
Here are some examples:
If you're talking about a home renovation that involves moving walls, altering plumbing or electrical, adding a room, expanding your living space, or changing the home's layout, it always requires a contractor. These kinds of projects affect the home's foundation, structure, or utility systems - areas that are strictly regulated by government and local building codes.
A bathroom remodel often requires moving pipes, upgrading fixtures, changing ventilation, and coordinating multiple trades. Only a contractor has the expertise, permits, and team to ensure everything is installed to code, safely, and long-lasting.
Anything involving structural beams, roofing replacement, complete siding, or major construction requires a contractor. These kinds of projects impact critical areas of the house and require advanced training.
If you want to create more usable space, modernize your floor plan, or boost your home's long-term value, a contractor is the way to go. Their renovation planning skills will ensure the success of these long-term projects.### 5. Time-Consuming Jobs Requiring Multiple Trades
Renovating an ample space is a beast of a project, requiring a team of specialists like plumbers, electricians, framers, flooring installers, and a whole lot more to get the job done, which is precisely why a contractor is usually the only one who can actually pull it all together effectively.
Need to get approvals, engineering drawings, or do some serious planning for your project? That's when a contractor comes into the picture.
Figuring out what you can expect to pay and getting an estimate is a big part of deciding whether a handyman or contractor is for you. And the truth is, a handyman usually costs less to hire because they're solo acts, have lower overhead, and typically handle only basic tasks.
Contractors, on the other hand, run a full-blown business - a registered company, often with staff, insurance requirements, and specialized crews. They've got to pay subcontractors, figure out which materials they need, and make sure they comply with all local regulations, so their prices tend to be higher. But then again, contractors work on bigger projects, so their work is generally higher quality, and naturally, they're more likely to follow the rules to the letter.
If your project is small and doesn't require any special skills beyond the usual household stuff, a handyman is your best bet.
Just want a new coat of paint (no significant changes) - a handyman will do the trick
Fixing some trim, painting, or just refreshing the look and feel of a room - all pretty standard stuff for a handyman to handle
Routine maintenance tasks like putting up shelves or assembling a bit of furniture
Swapping out small fixtures, or hanging some new shelves
You've got a small appliance that needs installing
You want to give your living space a quick facelift to refresh it.
Handypersons are really good for fixed-price, low-risk, short-term projects that don't require permits.
If you've got a large-scale renovation project that needs multiple trades, or if you're planning some significant structural changes to your home, or if you're looking at a serious bathroom remodel or electrical/plumbing upgrade, then a contractor is your best bet. They've got access to all the right people and equipment to get the job done.
You're doing a major renovation that involves multiple trades
You're planning some structural changes
You're looking to upgrade electrical or plumbing systems
You've got a high-budget renovation project
Safety is a top concern
You need engineered drawings
You're creating new layouts or adding extra space.
A contractor has the expertise, licenses, and team to tackle large, complex projects.
Touching up the paint job on an accent wall
Fixing a wee bit of drywall
Swapping out fixtures
Gutter cleaning
Installing some new light fixtures
Replacing old cabinet hardware
Fixing a leaky faucet
Putting in some new appliances
Replacing doors
Minor carpentry work
Installing a new door
Handypersons can handle these kinds of tasks because they don't require any special equipment, and homeowners can usually get a clear idea of the cost upfront.
Contractor work is best for the bigger, more complex projects that require extensive planning and serious attention to safety and code compliance. These are projects that require more than a single person to handle and need someone who can pull in all the necessary trades to get the job done.
A complete home renovation
A multi-room project
Major structural repairs
A whole new kitchen or bathroom
Siding replacement
New flooring throughout the house
Adding an extra room to the house
Major painting projects that will get you up on a scaffold
These are the kinds of projects where you don't want to take any chances and need to be sure your work will be done right and up to code.
Choosing the wrong guy for the job can lead to a whole lot of problems - like having to fix things twice, failed inspections, terrible finishes, delays, budget overruns, and safety hazards.
That's why getting the right professional for the job is so essential to your home's long-term success.
A contractor will be able to manage a project, bring in the right tradespeople, and give you a detailed plan. A handyman is all about flexibility, quick solutions, and keeping costs down. Both have a place - they're just designed for different kinds of jobs.
If you're still trying to decide whether to go with a handyman or a contractor, ask yourself these questions:
If so, call in a contractor.
Then a handyman is a good bet.
If it's complex or a bit iffy, choose a contractor.
Contractors are more geared toward long-term projects.
A handyman will do the trick for small-scale stuff.
Contractor companies are designed to provide a whole team of people behind the scenes.
The handyman vs. contractor debate is a common one in communities big and small across the country. In many towns, volunteers are an excellent help with cosmetic work, but for any project that involves actual building or fixtures, a professional is really the only way to go.
A lot of homeowners don't realize just how much is going on behind the walls - whether you're in a big city or a small suburb, the roles of handyman and contractor are the same everywhere.
While DIY projects can be tempting, especially for small jobs, more often than not, they end up being a bigger headache than they're worth, resulting in costly repairs down the road. Knowing when to call in a pro is a smart move, one that ends up saving you a world of trouble and keeping your home intact.
Hire a handyman for small jobs that don't pose a high risk, as they can be very effective for these tasks. Anything that requires a significant overhaul, reconfiguring structural elements, or tackling complicated technical work is better left to a contractor.
Before you dive into a project, take some time to talk to the right person. A handyman can give you a rough idea of what it'll cost for a basic job. At the same time, a contractor can lay out a complete timeline of what a renovation entails, including materials, budget, and all that other good stuff.
Both of them can give you peace of mind, knowing your home will look great today and will still look good years down the line.
Choosing the right pro for the job is vital to achieving the long-term outcome you want for your home, as they can provide the resources needed to ensure success. Whether you're dealing with a simple job that needs a handyman or a full-on overhaul that requires a contractor, working with the right expert helps ensure the project gets done right, safely, and without breaking the bank.
Handymen are perfect for small jobs that can give your place a facelift, help you cut costs, and handle the little jobs that keep your home looking refreshed and renewed. Contractors, on the other hand, are the ones to call for the major renovations. Such renovations involve overseeing a team, obtaining permits, and delivering a top-notch outcome.
If you're ever on the fence, start by asking some questions, getting a rough estimate, and looking over their portfolio or past work. You'll quickly figure out who's the right fit for your needs.
Your home matters - choose wisely, and you'll be well on your way to a super successful home renovation project.
